This last Sunday, I spoke at church about the gospel reading from Matthew 14:13-21, where Jesus feeds 5000 men, not counting women and children. Here is a good portion of my sermon and notes about it all.
When I read today's gospel, I notice a couple of important points that help us get started with this story. First is that compassion draws hungry people...even as Jesus was in mourning over his cousin John's beheading and death, he has compassion on the crowd that follows. He heals them...and they stay with him. Second is that this was clearly a eucharist story for the early church...a story that would bring some meaning and memories to what they did very often; they shared communion...they made eucharist.
This story also raises a question. Why did the disciples decide the crowd was hungry?
Sure, there was scarcity everywhere but nothing in the text tells us
why...I wonder if they were projecting? “I'm tired. I'm hungry.
Can we please get rid of these people Jesus?” After all, it seems like the crowd wasn't too concerned about dinner or sleep. They would've stayed with Jesus all night.
In John, Jesus
bypasses them and feeds the crowd himself which resonates with the
theology of the Johanine community from which the gospel comes...but
in Matthew, Jesus says “no—you feed them.”
Our eucharistic theology is so screwed up that we
have rules and regulations about who can bless the damn bread! We do
the same thing the disciples did... “Lord, send these people to an
ordained clergy person who can administer sacrament to them.” And
I know we don't do that here at this church...but do we? Do we have our own rules
about where and how and by whom God's bread is broken to share?
In the church world, we are so busy building up our
baskets, the Lord has gone hoarse from telling us to give these
people something to eat. I fear the church, like the disciples,
doesn't really have any food to offer anymore. Certainly, with all
churches in decline by traditional metrics, everyone else seems to
have concluded the same thing.
But, then, maybe we as church aren't the disciples
here...maybe we are the crowd...and Jesus is sending people to US to
break bread among us. Unlike the crowd here, we are so worried about
who made that food and whether or not it was kosher (“Who is the
mother of that boy that gave his lunch?!” we would've asked in another gospel's telling of this story...), we would rather starve
than be fed. And we encourage the rest of the hungry crowd to
abstain. And the Lord who wants to feed us tries in vain as the
church in God's name proclaims from pulpits “DON'T EAT THE BREAD!”
Instead of seeing yourself in the shoes of the
disciples today, find yourself among the crowd and call that crowd
“the church.” If the crowd is the church, then the question becomes who are the
disciples who are breaking bread to us in this narrative?
I would like to think they are unchurched people who are learning what
real compassion without strings attached looks like. They are apostates who left the church long ago
because of many reasons, but have found that they aren't different
people except in ways that make them happier, and gentler, and yes,
even godlier.
The disciples are messengers of peace from other
world religions and even other Christian denominations we would so
easily dismiss, because we think that truth is confined to one
outlet...and if we would listen to Truth, in whatever costume it
dresses itself up in, we would find that we are less hungry for it
after we eat...even as most of us would continue to focus on Jesus as
the author and finisher of our faith.
In my take, the disciples are atheists or agnostics
who value faith only if it can be questioned and tried...and if we
would accept the bread they are offering us, we would find our faith
enlivened and relevant because of the questions we would ask of
ourselves...or we might find ourselves abandoning our faith in
pursuit of truth outside the religious answers we've always known.
Does that scare you? Am I too radical to preach this
in a Christian church? I mean, if we all preach this, won't everyone
leave the church because they don't need it? I'm suggesting exactly
that to you—you don't NEED the church...but we do need each other.
And church is as good a place as any to really find each other...but
only so long as we tell the truth about ourselves and others. Church
has no value simply because it's the church...the value church has is
in what people bring to it.
And the story today teaches me that too. Yes, the
bread will come from the hands of disciples we are so quick to
dismiss and reject. But, more than that, it's important to remember
that they aren't providing the food that will feed us all...we are.
It's a little counterintuitive in this story isn't it? The disciples
don't save the crowd...the crowd has the food it needs to survive.
Jesus just gathers it and redistributes it. Now instead of one boy
with a sack lunch, they all have plenty with leftovers.
Now, I tend to believe that this is a miracle story
based on some historical event rather than a historical report about
a miracle event...so the multiplication of the loaves and fishes
isn't all that important to me except to teach us about how much we
truly have when we only think it is a little. But many if not most
of you will say “absolutely not...it's important that Jesus
multiplied those loaves and fishes.” And maybe you're right...but
even so, it's completely significant that Jesus doesn't turn stones
into bread to feed the people. He uses what they have. The crowd
has all it needs to be fed. But isn't that how the Divine that we
see at work in the world goes about doing things? Doesn't the spirit
take a little of what we have, sift it through the hands of some
people who might have even tried to just be getting rid of us, pass
it among our various crowds—churches, friends, families, dance
clubs, supper clubs, schoolrooms, etc—until we are all amazed at
how interconnected we are with one another?

I don't know what your idea of eucharist is, but if
it is confined to this table at church, you'll always go hungry. God is
feeding the world at many tables. Some of them in churches
today, yes...but at many other times and in many other places.
What it comes down to for me is this—I do believe.
Today, anyway. And I believe in the good news so much that I believe
it can withstand any doubt or disbelief and that those who search for
truth will find it...and I care very little if they find it in a
church or in a bar or in a movie theatre or a synagogue or mosque or
a temple or a country chapel or a orchestra concert, or a band
rehearsal, or a music festival or any other place. Because I
believe...in a God that is found in all of those places by many names
and in many different forms.
Does this sound completely apostate and heretical?
That must have been how this story sounded to the
first century listeners who heard it. God doesn't masquerade as a
carpenter from Galilee. God doesn't call fishermen and publicans.
God doesn't party with hookers and get drunk on the weekends like
Jesus. That's not how God works, they say. But it is.
So, join the crowd. Seriously...the crowd in this
story...and find eucharist outside these walls. You'll starve if you
only look for it from the church. Because I fear the church has seen
itself as the disciples in this story for so long instead of the
crowd, that they've starved to death, rejecting the bread God is
bringing through unlikely sources. But the bread is there. It is
exactly where Jesus said the kingdom of God is. Among us.
I haven't lost hope.
I believe food will come from somewhere...but not until we start
asking the right questions of ourselves and others. Not until we
start caring about people rather than personal utility or the groups
we are trying to use people to build up. And I DO believe that the
church of Jesus Christ can be disciples, distributing the bread of
hope that the crowd had with them all along right back among them and
feeding the hungry. But we'll never get there until we can begin to
find our own hunger again and bring our own stories and struggles and
questions to the table.
Let us pray.
May the God who satisfies the hungry soul help us
to see what we have need of in our own souls. May She bring out from
among us the gifts that will feed not only our souls but the hearts
of our neighbors and the stomachs of a physically hungry world. And
may we never be satisfied with believing that God is confined by one
sack lunch, or by our ideas of propriety, or by our concepts of what
is “best” or “right.” In other words, Lord, thy kingdom come
and thy will be done on earth as it is in heaven. And give us this
day our daily bread...